How to get compliant with the Protected Disclosures Act in Ireland

How to get compliant with the Protected Disclosures Act in Ireland
This whitepaper aims to provide an overview and understanding of the whistleblower protection legislation in Ireland. It covers key provisions, legal requirements, and step-by-step obligations for organisations.
 
The purpose of the Irish Protected Disclosures Act is to safeguard individuals who report violations of national or European Union law, that harm the public interest or the integrity of public administration or private entities, of which they have become aware in their work context. The law aims to protect these
individuals from retaliation and promote transparency and accountability. The term ‘whistleblower’ is not used in the Protected Disclosures Act. The legislation refers to making a protected disclosure, which is a particular type of report by a worker, related to wrongdoings in the workplace.
Overview on the Irish legislation on whistleblower protection
The process to transpose the EU Whistleblowing Directive (2019/1937) into Irish law began in June 2020, with a public consultation by the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform. The Directive necessitated several significant amendments to Ireland’s Protected Disclosures Act 2014. A General Scheme of the amended act, aimed at enhancing the existing legislation, was published in May 2021.
 
As Ireland failed to meet the 17 December 2021 deadline, the European Commission initiated infringement proceedings against the country, along with 23 other countries, in January 2022. Shortly after, Ireland published a new whistleblower protection act on 9 February 2022. The Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Bill 2022 was signed by Ireland’s President on 21 July 2022,
making Ireland the eleventh Member State to transpose the EU Directive on Whistleblower Protection. The new law came into force on 1 January 2023.
 
However, civil society has raised concerns that the new law may actually be a step backwards in protecting whistleblowers, arguing that some measures could weaken existing protections. A new legal regulation to amend the whistleblowing law was passed in July 2022, addressing concerns raised by the EU Commission regarding the equal treatment of persons reporting breaches to relevant Union institutions as well as externally to national authorities.
 

The Government has since published comprehensive guidance on whistleblowing to assist public bodies in understanding their obligations under the new Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Act 2022. Additionally, two template policies for handling internal and external reports have been published.

The amended Protected Disclosures Act expands protection against retaliation, including attempted retaliation, to individuals who make a protected disclosure through designated reporting channels:

  1. Any act or omission that may constitute a violation of EU law, provided it falls within the scope of acts listed in the Annex to the Whistleblowing Directive, affects the financial interests of the European Union or impacts the internal market. This includes infringements on competition and State aid rules, as well as tax rules.

  2.  Wrongdoings in a work-related context including:
  • a. Criminal offences
  • b. Failure to comply with legal obligations
  • c. Miscarriage of justice
  • d. Misuse of public funds
  • e. Oppressive, discriminatory, grossly negligent, or grossly mismanaged acts or omissions by a public body
  • f. Concealment or destruction of information about any of the above wrongdoing or any attempt to conceal or destroy such information.
Key provisions and legal requirements
The Irish Protected Disclosures Act aligns with the minimum standards outlined in the EU Whistleblower Protection Directive, and significantly broadens the scope of the previously existing legislation on whistleblower protection. Internal reporting channels for whistleblowing must adhere to certain requirements outlined by the law.
 

1. All legal entities with 50 or more employees, must create a policy setting out the reporting channels and procedures for employees to make protected disclosures. 

2. Obliged organisations must establish channels for reporting violations of national and union law or serious wrongdoings. These internal reporting channels must be easily accessible by all employees, and the company needs to provide clear information on their website regarding the use of these channels and the internal procedure for managing reports. 

3. The channel for protected disclosures must securely protect the confidentiality of the reporting person’s identity and any third party named in the report, by its design, structure, and management.

4. The company must assign a designated, impartial individual to oversee the internal reporting channel. All reports must be investigated and diligently followed up by the designated person.

5. There is no obligation to accept of follow up anonymous reports, but any anonymous whistleblower who is subsequently identified is entitled to the same protection. 

6. Reporting can take place verbally or in writing. The whistleblower can also request a face-to-face meeting.

7. Acknowledgment of the receipt of every whistleblowing report must be provided to the reporting person within seven days.

8. Feedback on the follow-up or investigation must be provided to the whistleblower within three months (can be extended to six months in certain justified cases).
Whistleblowers should be given information on the final outcome of any investigations.

9. Reversed burden of proofs means employers will have to prove that reprisals are not related to whistleblowing.

10. Records must be kept of every report received and the internal whistleblowing channels must use an appropriate encryption system for data protection and confidentiality throughout the entire process. All processing of personal data must be done in accordance with GDPR.

Deadlines

Private sector and charity employers with 250 or more employees were required to comply with the new procedures and establish a secure, impartial, and confidential internal reporting channel by 1 January 2023.

For companies with between 50 and 249 employees, the implementation deadline for reporting channels was December 17, 2023.

Employers in financial services, products and markets, prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, transport safety, and protection of the environment had to comply from 1 January 2023 regardless of the number of employees, this is also true for all public bodies.

Applicable penalties for non-compliance

Applicable penalties for non-compliance with whistleblowing regulations include hindering or penalising workers from making reports, bringing vexatious proceedings against reporting persons, and failing to establish internal reporting channels. Such offences can result in fines of up to €250,000 and/or imprisonment for up to two years.

Breaching the duty of confidentiality can result in fines up to €75,000 and/or imprisonment for up to two years. Corporate entities can also be held liable for offences committed with the consent or neglect of directors or officers, who may face similar penalties as the corporation.

Whistleblowers penalised for making protected disclosures could receive compensation equivalent to up to 5 years’ pay if they received salary from
the organisation.

Knowingly making a report with false information is punishable by a fine of up to €100,000 and/or imprisonment for up to 2 years. Whistleblowers cannot be penalised if they had reasonable grounds to believe that the reported information was true at the time of reporting.

Identifying Whistleblower Protection Obligations

Whistleblower protection obligations refer to the legal and ethical responsibilities of organisations to safeguard individuals who report wrongdoing or illegal activities within the workplace.

1

Determining if your organisation is subject to the law
For the private sector, the obligation to implement reporting channels, adopt procedures for reporting and ensuring whistleblower protection applies to the following organisations:
 
  1. Legal entities with 50 or more employees with permanent or fixed-term employment contracts.
  2. All organisations in the areas of financial services entities; prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, transport safety, and safety of offshore gas and oil operations must establish internal channels regardless of the number of employees.
  3. Non-profit organisations, associations, foundations, and other similar entities are also affected by the law. 

For the public sector, the law has extended the obligation to have internal reporting channels to its full extent. All public entities must set up a secure reporting system
regardless of the number of employees 
 
Legal entities in the private sector with less than 250 employees may share resources for receiving and investigating protected disclosures.

2

Understanding the scope of protection for whistleblowers

Whistleblower protection extends to employees (current and former), contractors, individuals on work experience, agency workers, volunteers and trainees,
shareholders, board members and job applicants

Protection includes prohibition of retaliation, also indirect, against the reporting person. This includes e.g., dismissal, suspension, downgrading or non-promotion, demotion, negative references, intimidation or harassment, reputational damage, or otherwise unfavourable treatment. Protection also includes benefits from support measures provided by third-sector organisations (such as information, assistance, and advice on how to report, the rights of the person concerned and access to legal aid).

Protection does not apply to:
  1. Personal disputes or claims linked to an exclusively personal interest of the reporting person.
  2. Reports already regulated by EU or national acts.
  3. Reports related to national security or defence, medical affairs, confidentiality between a lawyer and a client as well as the secrecy of judicial deliberations are all excluded.
  4. Reports from persons whose job it is to detect, investigate or prosecute any wrongdoing and if the wrongdoing reported relates to a person other than the employer.

A whistleblower is protected even if the information is proved to be incorrect, provided they had reasonable belief in the information at the time of reporting.

Establishing Whistleblower Protection Policies and Procedures

To comply with the Irish law on whistleblower protection, organisations should:

1. Develop a comprehensive whistleblower policy
The company must create a policy on how to use the internal reporting channel, how to submit a report, what to include in a report, and indicate how the reports will be handled. Employee representatives or trade unions must be consulted.
2. Designate responsible individuals or departments

Employers must also appoint someone to investigate whistleblower claims. That person or department must have autonomy to investigate and follow-up as necessary.

3. Establish secure channels for reporting and protection

The internal whistleblowing channels must be easily accessible by all stakeholders and easily found on the organisation’s website. Digital platforms or whistleblower systems such as Whistlelink’s all-in-one solution can offer valuable support for the organised management of whistleblowing.

4. Ensure confidentiality and anonymity

Whistleblowers are allowed to submit anonymous reports; but an organisation’s legal responsibility is to protect the confidentiality of whistleblowers.

5. Document and maintain proper records

For all reports received in the internal reporting system, records must be kept in compliance with data protection laws. Feedback on the investigation must be
provided to the whistleblower within three months.

5. Document and maintain proper records

Data controllers must implement a combination of organisational and technical measures to protect the confidentiality of the whistleblower, and the integrity and confidentiality of any personal data reported. An appropriate encryption system must be used throughout the entire process.

Organisations are required to adhere to data protection principles and requirements, including those set forth in the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), when processing personal data collected through whistleblowing reports.

According to the GDPR, personal data should not be kept for longer than is necessary for the purposes for which it was collected. Therefore, organisations should establish clear retention periods for personal data collected through whistleblowing reports, taking into account factors such as the nature of the reported misconduct, the potential legal or regulatory requirements, and any applicable statutes of limitations.

Informing and Raising Awareness

Train employees on whistleblower rights and procedures. Ensure employees are aware of their rights, the protections in place to prevent retaliation, and understand
the importance of reporting any wrongdoing they witness.

2

Acknowledge the right to external reporting

In most cases, internal reporting channels within the organisation should be the preferred method for whistleblowers to raise their concerns. However, whistleblowers may also choose to use external reporting channels such as the Office of the Protected Disclosures Commissioner.

A whistleblower may also report to one of the prescribed persons listed in the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 Order 2020. In general, prescribed persons have regulatory functions in the area which are the subject of the allegations. A list of prescribed persons can be found at:
http://www.gov.ie/prescribed-persons

For external disclosures, the information and any allegations must be substantially true, by reasonable belief.

Whistleblowers should be informed of their rights and provided with guidance on how to access external reporting channels effectively and safely. Organisations must include information on external reporting in their whistleblowing policy.

1

Encourage internal reporting and address potential concerns

Early detection of issues allows for addressing concerns at an early stage, preventing them from escalating into more significant problems. Handling concerns internally will help organisations maintain their reputation and credibility.

By creating a culture that values transparency and accountability, employees will feel more comfortable coming forward with their concerns. This can be achieved through regular training and communication, ensuring that employees understand the importance of reporting potential misconduct and the protections in place for whistleblowers.

Get compliant with the whistleblowing law in Ireland – step by step

1

Identify whistleblower protection obligations

2

Establish whistleblowing policies and procedures

3

Raise awareness
We kindly invite you to reach out to us to discuss a secure whistleblowing solution.

Nice to meet you!

Get in touch

Our team would like to offer you a free demo of Whistlelink.
Please select a suitable time in our calendar.

Talk with Territory Manager
Annelie Demred

0046 (0)706 83 82 88

HAPPY TO MEET YOU!

Get in touch

Our team is ready to answer your questions.
Fill out the form below and we'll be in touch as soon as possible.

Talk with Territory Manager
Annelie Demred

annelie.demred@whistlelink.com

HAPPY TO MEET YOU!

Get in touch

Our team is ready to answer your questions. Find the answer by visiting our support centre, or fill out the form below and we'll be in touch as soon as possible. Or simply give us a call!

Talk with Territory Manager
Annelie Demred

annelie.demred@whistlelink.com